Determination Of Indices (Flakiness And Elongation)

✓
Written by Help The Engineer Team
Reviewed by Er. Inderjit Sharma (Retd.), Punjab PWD

What is this test? It checks the shape of coarse aggregate. Good aggregate is roughly cubical. Pieces that are too thin (flaky) or too long (elongated) are weak and pack badly.

Why it matters: flaky and elongated stones break under rollers and traffic, leave more voids, need more cement or bitumen, and make concrete less workable. So specifications limit how many such pieces are allowed.

This guide follows IS 2386 (Part 1), with the combined index used in MoRTH specifications.

Good Shape vs Bad Shape

✓ Cubicalall sides about equalstrong, packs well t✗ Flakythickness < 0.6 × mean sizethin, breaks easily length L✗ Elongatedlength > 1.8 × mean sizelong, snaps under load Mean size = average of the two sieves (e.g. 20–16 mm → 18 mm)
Fig. 1: Cubical stones are best. Flaky stones are too thin; elongated stones are too long.

📏 Flakiness Index (FI)

Percentage by weight of pieces whose thickness is less than 0.6 times their mean size.

📐 Elongation Index (EI)

Percentage by weight of pieces whose length is more than 1.8 times their mean size.

➕ Combined Index

FI + EI. Most current specifications set a limit on this combined value.

Why Shape Matters

Cubical: locks togetherfew voids, strong layer Flaky: gaps and breakagemore voids, more binder, weak layer
Fig. 2: Cubical stones lock together. Flaky stones leave gaps and snap under the roller.

Apparatus Required

Thickness gauge

Steel plate with slots of different widths; flaky pieces pass through.

Length gauge

Base with pairs of pins; elongated pieces won’t pass between the pins.

IS sieves

63, 50, 40, 31.5, 25, 20, 16, 12.5, 10 and 6.3 mm.

1250 g

Balance (1 g)

15 kg capacity; weighs each fraction.

Oven

Dries the sample at 105–110 °C.

Trays & scoop

Keep each size fraction separate.

How the Gauges Work

Thickness gauge Passes through the slot→ FLAKY slot width = 0.6 × mean size gap = 1.8 × mean Length gauge Too long to fit between the pins→ ELONGATED
Fig. 3: A stone that slips through the slot is flaky. A stone that won’t fit lengthwise between the pins is elongated.

Gauge Sizes for Each Fraction

Size fraction (passing–retained)Thickness gauge slot (0.6 × mean)Length gauge gap (1.8 × mean)
63–50 mm33.90 mm–
50–40 mm27.00 mm81.0 mm
40–25 mm19.50 mm58.5 mm
31.5–25 mm16.95 mm–
25–20 mm13.50 mm40.5 mm
20–16 mm10.80 mm32.4 mm
16–12.5 mm8.55 mm25.6 mm
12.5–10 mm6.75 mm20.2 mm
10–6.3 mm4.89 mm14.7 mm

As per IS 2386 (Part 1). The test is for aggregate larger than 6.3 mm.

Procedure

  1. Take a representative sample from the stockpile (by quartering, not by picking stones by hand).
  2. Dry it at 105–110 °C to constant weight and let it cool.
  3. Sieve it into the size fractions in the table above. Take at least 200 pieces from each fraction and weigh them (A).
  4. Flakiness: try each piece through the matching slot of the thickness gauge. Weigh the pieces that pass (C).
  5. Elongation: take the pieces that did not pass (non-flaky) and try each lengthwise between the matching pins of the length gauge. Weigh the pieces that don’t fit (E).
  6. Add up the weights of all fractions and calculate.

Calculation

Flakiness Index (%) = ΣC ÷ ΣA × 100
Elongation Index (%) = ΣE ÷ (ΣA − ΣC) × 100
Combined Index (%) = FI + EI

Report to two decimal places. In the combined (MoRTH) method, elongation is worked out on the non-flaky part of the sample.

Try It: Flakiness & Elongation Calculator

Enter the weights (g) for each fraction you tested. Leave unused fractions blank. The values filled in are a worked example.

Precautions

🎲 Don’t hand-pick

Take the sample at random by quartering. Picking “nice” stones hides the real shape.

🎯 Right slot, right pins

Use the slot and pin pair that match each size fraction.

✋ Don’t force

Try each piece gently; don’t push a stone through the slot or between the pins.

🔢 Enough pieces

At least 200 pieces per fraction, so the result is reliable.

Practical Tips for Site Engineers

1. Typical Limits (Combined FI + EI)

UseMaximum combined index
Wet Mix Macadam (WMM)35% (MoRTH)
Bituminous layers (DBM, BC)35% (MoRTH)
Concrete aggregate40% (IS 383:2016)

Older specifications set separate limits (for example 30% for roads, 25% for concrete). Always follow the limit in your contract.

2. Where Bad Shape Comes From

⚙️ Crusher type

Jaw crushers alone tend to produce flaky stone. A cone or VSI crusher as the final stage gives more cubical aggregate.

🪨 Rock type

Layered rocks (shale, slate, some schists) naturally break into flat pieces.

🔧 Worn crusher settings

Worn jaws and wrong settings increase flaky output; ask the plant to check and adjust.

3. Good Site Habits

  1. Test at the source first: check samples from the crusher before approving it, and again on regular deliveries.
  2. Look before you test: a handful of stone from the stockpile shows a lot. Many thin “chips” or long “slivers” mean a test is due.
  3. Sample the stockpile properly: take from top, middle and bottom, and mix and quarter it. Avoid picking only from the surface.
  4. Reject or rectify: if the combined index is high, ask the supplier to change crusher settings or source. Don’t accept it just because it’s on site.
  5. Keep test records with date, source, quantity represented and result, as required by MoRTH test frequencies.
  6. Remember the other tests: shape is one check; impact value, abrasion value, water absorption and grading also decide acceptance.

Key Takeaways

  • Flaky: thickness < 0.6 × mean size. Elongated: length > 1.8 × mean size.
  • Sieve into fractions, take at least 200 pieces each, and use the matching gauge slot and pins.
  • FI = ΣC ÷ ΣA × 100; EI = ΣE ÷ non-flaky weight × 100; Combined = FI + EI.
  • Typical combined limits: 35% for WMM and bituminous layers, 40% for concrete (IS 383:2016).
  • On site: the crusher decides the shape. Test at the source, sample properly, and reject flaky material.

References: IS 2386 (Part 1): Methods of Test for Aggregates – Particle Size and Shape; IS 383:2016: Coarse and Fine Aggregate for Concrete; MoRTH Specifications for Road and Bridge Works (Tables 400-12, 500-8, 500-16).

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *